Stayed at Deep Blue and it was great! Depends I think what you are looking for. for me, after researching I narrowed it down to Mango Inn or DB. Both had great reviews. i went with DB because of Steve’s knowledge of whale sharks as well as I was positive there was hot water. yep! that is a requirement for me. I looked that the website and what I remember most of the lodges were offering some good prices for the week. I love Utila. wish I could make it there for that fest