Hi Andy,
There are several locations we could dive, the one in mind is called "Garbage Beach" which is a good spot, but I hate that name, you can Google for it, there were many ships anchoring there 300 years ago, it is a natural harbor and was used by the old whaling ships and colonial war era ships, so there is a lot of old artifacts but no garbage.
Are you actually considering a drive from NY? It’s 4 hours.
Thanks for replying,
Dan